Governance

When leadership opportunity becomes a trap

Being appointed to lead an organisation through a crisis can look like an opportunity. But for the person taking the role, the organisation and its board, the consequences can be significant.


The incoming leader may inherit deep-rooted problems, damaged relationships, unrealistic expectations and limited authority to make the changes required. The organisation risks losing another leader without addressing the issues that caused the crisis. And the board may find itself holding a leader accountable for outcomes that depend on decisions, resources and behaviours well beyond that person's control.


The effects can extend beyond an individual appointment. They can undermine transformation, reinforce organisational dysfunction and create further leadership instability.

These are some of the risks associated with the glass cliff, and they deserve closer attention from boards and executives.


The article explores the research, organisational implications and what needs to change to ensure leadership appointments are supported by the conditions for success.

Axis of Action 19 November 2026
When leadership opportunity becomes a trap

Organisational change often creates pressure to demonstrate that something is different. When an organisation faces a crisis, sustained underperformance, reputational damage or a major transformation, its board or executive team may conclude that a different type of leadership is needed. This can lead to the appointment of a new chief executive, a transformation leader, a restructured senior management team or someone charged with leading a turnaround programme.


In some cases, the person appointed is a woman or another member of an underrepresented group. The appointment may be intended to signal renewal, restore stakeholder confidence or show that the organisation has moved beyond the decisions and behaviours that contributed to its difficulties. It may also reflect a genuine judgement that the organisation needs a different kind of leadership.


But appointing a new leader does not, by itself, change an organisation. If the causes of the crisis remain unaddressed, the incoming leader may inherit unrealistic expectations, limited authority, insufficient resources and resistance from the very people needed to deliver change. What is presented as an opportunity to lead can become a role in which failure is more likely than success. This phenomenon has been studied and called the glass cliff. It is often described as the opposite of the glass ceiling: rather than preventing underrepresented groups from reaching senior leadership, it describes what can happen once they get there. The comparison is useful, but incomplete. The glass ceiling limits access to leadership. The glass cliff concerns the conditions attached to particular leadership roles. Both can operate at the same time. A person may overcome barriers to appointment, only to be placed in a role where the likelihood of failure is already high.


The glass cliff is therefore not simply a question of who is appointed. It asks why they were appointed, what they have been asked to fix, whether they have the authority and resources to succeed, and whether the organisation is prepared to share responsibility for the outcome.


Origins and evidence

The term was introduced by Michelle Ryan and Alexander Haslam in 2005, following evidence that women were over-represented among directors appointed to poorly performing UK companies. Subsequent research found similar patterns in politics, sport, law and public administration.


The strongest synthesis to date, a 2020 meta-analysis by Morgenroth, Kirby, Ryan and Sudkämper, examined archival field studies and experimental studies of leadership suitability and selection. It found some support for a glass cliff effect for women across all three bodies of evidence, although the archival effect was small and varied by organisational domain.

Evidence streamWhat it testsMain finding
Archival field studiesWhether underrepresented groups are appointed during organisational crisisA small glass cliff effect, dependent on domain
Experimental suitability studiesWhether people rate women as more suitable in a crisisA small effect in between-participants designs, but not within-participants designs
Experimental selection studiesWhether women are chosen over men in a crisisWomen were more likely to be selected in a crisis. The effect was stronger in countries with greater gender inequality
Racial and ethnic minority leadersWhether the pattern extends beyond genderEvidence indicates the glass cliff can also affect underrepresented racial and ethnic groups

The pattern appears across sectors and organisations. At Qantas, Vanessa Hudson became CEO after the airline faced intense public backlash, regulatory action and reputational damage. At Woolworths, Amanda Bardwell was appointed the company’s first female CEO amid cost-of-living scrutiny, regulatory inquiries into grocery pricing and sustained media pressure. At Virgin Australia, Jayne Hrdlicka took the role when the airline was near collapse and later described the period as heavy lifting across the organisation during the toughest of times. At the Reserve Bank, Michele Bullock’s appointment as Governor followed a period of sustained public criticism of interest-rate decisions and their impact on households. In listed companies more broadly, research examining chief executive transitions has found that women and ethnic minority leaders were more likely than others to be appointed when firms were experiencing weak performance, including cases at Air New Zealand during severe financial stress and at Restaurant Brands amid historic underinvestment.


These appointments illustrate the same underlying dynamic: capable leaders stepping into highly visible roles when risk, scrutiny and inherited problems are elevated.


Why it happens


Stereotypes and “think crisis, think female”

Social psychological research suggests that crises can change which leadership traits people consider valuable. In stable conditions, stereotypically agentic traits often associated with men, such as decisiveness, competitiveness and control, may dominate leadership ideals. In a crisis, stereotypically communal traits often associated with women, such as empathy, communication and relationship building, become more prominent.


Bruckmüller and Branscombe’s experiments found that participants preferred a male leader for a successful organisation but a female leader during a crisis, particularly when the organisation had a history of male leadership. Their second experiment suggested that the effect was partly driven by men being seen as lacking crisis-relevant communal attributes, rather than women being uniquely idealised.


Signalling change

A crisis can create pressure to demonstrate that something is changing. Appointing a woman, or another person who visibly departs from the previous leadership profile, can function as a symbolic signal of renewal. The appointment communicates that the organisation is moving in a different direction, even when the underlying problems remain unresolved.


This is particularly relevant during organisational transformation. Boards and executives may appoint a new leader to demonstrate a break from the past, restore confidence or create momentum for change. However, the appointment itself does not change the organisation’s structures, behaviours, decision-making processes or culture.


Research on crisis attribution finds that the glass cliff is more likely when poor performance is attributed to previous leadership and when a new leader is perceived as capable of signalling change. This helps explain why the pattern is not simply that women are chosen in all difficult circumstances. It is more likely when the crisis is framed as a leadership failure requiring a visible break from the past.


Structural precarity

The glass cliff is also a business and organisational design problem, not merely a bias problem. Leaders appointed during decline may inherit weak financial resources, low staff morale, damaged stakeholder trust, unrealistic targets and limited authority to make changes. These conditions make failure more likely, regardless of who is appointed.


This becomes particularly apparent during organisational change. A leader may be brought in to restructure an organisation, improve performance, change its culture or deliver a major transformation, but discover that the organisation is not equipped or willing to support the change. The mandate may be ambitious while the authority to make decisions is constrained. Resources may be insufficient while expectations remain high. Senior stakeholders may publicly support the transformation but privately resist the decisions and behaviours required to deliver it.


In these circumstances, the leader is held accountable for an outcome that depends on much more than their individual capability. Rink, Ryan and Stoker found that the glass cliff effect weakened when stakeholders signalled that a newly appointed leader would receive social support. Where support was absent, gendered assumptions about agentic and communal leadership became more influential.


Responsibility without the means to deliver

There is an important distinction between being given responsibility for change and being given the conditions to deliver it. Three recurring issues help explain why a leadership appointment can become precarious.


First, a new leader may be expected to improve performance, restore confidence or change organisational culture without the underlying causes being addressed. Those causes may include poor governance, ineffective decision-making, entrenched behaviours, inadequate investment or unresolved leadership tensions. If they are not acknowledged and addressed, the new leader inherits the consequences without necessarily having the authority to change the systems that produced them.


Second, appointing a different leader can create an immediate perception of renewal. It can reassure stakeholders, demonstrate responsiveness and provide a visible break from the past. But organisational change requires more than a change in leadership. It involves shifting the structures, processes, behaviours, relationships and decision-making practices that determine how an organisation operates. Where the appointment is treated as the change itself, rather than as one part of a broader transformation, expectations can quickly become disconnected from reality.


Third, transformation requires active sponsorship, aligned leadership, organisational capacity and the willingness to make difficult decisions. A leader cannot deliver sustainable change alone. They depend on the support of the board, executive colleagues, managers, employees and other stakeholders. Where this support is absent, fragmented or conditional, the leader may find themselves accountable for delivering change while working within the very conditions that prevent it.


This creates a significant organisational risk. The failure of a transformation can be attributed to the person leading it, rather than to the governance, resources, organisational readiness or leadership behaviours that constrained its delivery.


Relevant theories

Theory or frameworkHow it explains the glass cliff
Social role theoryGender stereotypes arise from socially assigned roles. Leadership is traditionally coded masculine, while crisis-response traits may be coded feminine.
Stereotype content and role congruityPeople evaluate leaders against expectations for their social group. Women may be seen as suitable only when the situation makes communal traits seem necessary.
Social identity theoryCrisis threatens group identity and status. Selecting a visibly different leader can help restore a sense of collective change and renewal.
Attribution theoryWhen failure is attributed to former leaders’ decisions, appointing a demographically different successor becomes a way to signal accountability and change.
Resource dependence and organisational contingencyA leader’s ability to succeed depends on authority, budget, information, political backing and stakeholder support, not individual competence alone.
Behaviour-change theorySymbolic appointments can create the appearance of change without changing the systems, incentives and resources that produced the crisis.


The behavioural paradox

A common objection is that women may simply choose risky roles because they see opportunity where others see danger. Research complicates that explanation. Darouei and Pluut found that women often perceive themselves as more risk-averse in career decisions, yet may still accept precarious leadership roles because they perceive greater promotional opportunity. Career self-efficacy influenced this relationship.


That does not mean women choose the cliff. It means organisations may present risky roles as rare opportunities, while offering fewer equivalent pathways to stable senior leadership. The result can be a risk tax: underrepresented leaders are asked to accept disproportionately hazardous roles as the price of advancement.


Why it matters for business and organisational change

For organisations, the glass cliff creates several connected risks.

  • Leadership failure risk: A capable leader is placed in a role with inadequate resources, mandate or time to succeed.
  • Transformation risk: Organisational change is treated as a leadership appointment or restructuring exercise rather than a systemic process requiring changes to behaviours, structures and ways of working.
  • Governance risk: Boards and executives may set unrealistic expectations without addressing the conditions necessary to achieve them.
  • Reputation risk: If the appointment or transformation fails, observers may incorrectly attribute the outcome to the leader’s identity rather than the inherited crisis and organisational constraints.
  • Diversity risk: Organisations may treat one high-profile appointment as evidence of inclusion while leaving the underlying leadership pipeline, sponsorship and promotion systems unchanged.
  • Organisational capacity risk: The organisation may underestimate the time, resources and collective commitment required to support a turnaround or transformation.


The deeper issue is that diversity becomes performative when organisations appoint underrepresented leaders mainly during emergencies but do not give them the conditions needed to lead effectively. Equally, organisational transformation becomes performative when leaders are expected to deliver a different future without addressing the systems, behaviours and organisational conditions that determine whether change can happen.


What good practice looks like

Preventing glass cliffs requires changing the appointment system, not merely diversifying the person appointed. It also requires treating organisational change as a collective responsibility rather than an individual leadership task.


Audit appointment contexts

Track whether women and minority candidates are disproportionately offered turnaround, interim or hard-to-win roles. Examine whether these appointments come with the same authority, resources and opportunities as appointments in more stable organisations.

  1. Define the mandate - Specify decision rights, budget authority, board support, success measures and a realistic timeframe before appointment. Be clear about what the leader can control and what requires wider organisational commitment.
  2. Assess the organisation’s readiness for change - Understand the existing organisational conditions before expecting a new leader to deliver transformation. This includes leadership alignment, employee confidence, organisational capacity, culture, decision-making and the willingness to address difficult issues.
  3. Provide resources and support- Ensure access to trusted senior sponsors, operational capacity, accurate information and stakeholder support. A leader should not be expected to deliver significant change without the organisational backing required to make it possible.
  4. Separate signal from substance - Ask whether the appointment changes decision-making power, organisational behaviours and resources, or simply changes the public image of leadership. A new appointment should be supported by meaningful changes to the conditions that produced the original problems.
  5. Evaluate systemic causes- Assess whether the crisis resulted from governance, incentive design, underinvestment, organisational culture or previous leadership choices. Do not place responsibility for systemic problems solely on the incoming leader.
  6. Build a stable leadership pipeline - Develop underrepresented leaders for both growth and crisis roles, rather than reserving high-risk appointments for firsts. Ensure that access to senior leadership is not dependent on accepting disproportionately difficult circumstances.


A more accurate framing

The glass cliff is best understood as a system-level leadership and organisational risk phenomenon. Gendered stereotypes may influence who is selected, but organisational crises, weak social support, limited authority and symbolic change-making determine whether that selection becomes an opportunity or a trap.


The connection with organisational change makes the issue even more significant. Organisations frequently look to new leaders to provide the impetus for transformation. Yet sustainable change depends on more than individual leadership capability. It requires the organisation to recognise the problems it needs to address, provide the authority and resources to act, and create the conditions for people to change how they work.


A leader can set direction, challenge established thinking and create momentum. They cannot independently overcome entrenched organisational behaviours, conflicting priorities, weak governance or a lack of genuine commitment to change.


The practical question for boards and executives should ask: Are we giving every leader a role they can realistically succeed in, and are we prepared to address the organisational conditions that determine whether they can deliver meaningful and sustainable change?