Transformation

Empathy in leadership and why it matters most during organisational change

Empathy is not a soft skill. It is one of the hardest and most practical tools in leadership, especially during organisational change.

Most transformations do not fail because the strategy was wrong. They fail because people felt the change was being done to them, not with them.

The leaders who succeed take time to understand how different groups are experiencing the shift, name the real fears, and close the experience gap. If it took months for the leadership team to align, no one else should be expected to catch up after a single announcement.

Microsoft under Nadella, Campbell Soup under Conant, and Starbucks under Schultz all show what becomes possible when empathy is treated as infrastructure rather than decoration. The opposite cases show how quickly trust erodes when it is missing.

Empathy has limits. Not every form of resistance is emotional. Without clear direction and follow-through, it can feel hollow. But ignoring it almost always creates unnecessary friction.

For leaders navigating significant change, developing this capability is rarely optional. The full article explores the evidence, the limits, and what effective practice looks like in more depth.

Axis of Action 10 November 2026
Empathy in leadership and why it matters most during organisational change

Empathy is no longer a soft skill reserved for the people side of business. It is a practical leadership capability that shapes trust, engagement, innovation and the odds that major change will actually stick. When organisations attempt transformation, whether new strategies, systems, structures or cultures, empathy often becomes the decisive variable between adoption and resistance.


How leaders communicate change frequently matters more than what they communicate. Too many executives still plan major shifts while giving little real attention to how their people are experiencing the upheaval. The predictable result is that employees feel the change is being done to them rather than with them.


What empathetic leadership looks like in practice

Empathetic leaders do three things consistently. They seek to understand others’ perspectives without immediately judging or fixing. They acknowledge the emotional reality of a situation, even when the facts are non-negotiable. And they adjust their communication and involvement strategies accordingly. In ordinary times this builds psychological safety and discretionary effort. During change it becomes essential infrastructure.


Practical moves include profiling different audience groups and refreshing that understanding as the change unfolds, naming specific fears rather than glossing over them, and giving people at every level a genuine stake in shaping how the new reality lands. If it took the leadership team months of debate to reach a decision, it is unreasonable to expect everyone else to align after a single announcement. Closing that experience gap is where empathy does its heaviest lifting.

Leaders also need to diagnose the root of resistance. Some objections are logical and respond to better data. Some are relational and need time, rapport and shared criteria. Some are rooted in deeper values or identity and may require a different messenger or a different approach entirely. Empathy helps with accurate diagnosis and is central to the relational path.


Where empathy made a difference

Microsoft under Satya Nadella offers one of the clearest large-scale examples. When Nadella became CEO in 2014 the company was widely viewed as bureaucratic, internally competitive and culturally stagnant. He made empathy and a shift from a “know-it-all” to a “learn-it-all” mindset central to the reset. He invested in listening, removed the stack-ranking system that pitted employees against one another, and modelled curiosity about both colleagues and customers. Collaboration improved, innovation regained energy, and the company’s market value rose dramatically. Nadella has been open about the personal roots of this emphasis, including the experience of raising a son with severe disabilities. The transformation is extensively documented in his own writing, teaching cases and independent analysis, making it open to scrutiny.


Doug Conant’s decade at Campbell Soup provides another strong illustration. He inherited a company with among the worst employee engagement scores in the Fortune 500 and a toxic culture. Alongside hard operational decisions, Conant wrote more than 30,000 personal handwritten notes to employees over ten years, recognising specific contributions. Engagement moved from near the bottom of the Fortune 500 to world-class levels, and financial performance recovered. The combination of tough standards and consistent, personal recognition is well recorded across multiple independent accounts.


Howard Schultz’s return to Starbucks in 2008 shows empathy operating under intense pressure. The company was losing its way. Schultz publicly owned the leadership failures, closed thousands of stores for a single afternoon of barista retraining, and brought store managers together in New Orleans for a costly but deliberate gathering focused on reconnecting with purpose and people. He emphasised transparency, accountability and the human relationships at the heart of the brand.


Anne Mulcahy’s turnaround at Xerox followed a similar logic. Facing near-bankruptcy, she spent heavily on listening, logging extensive travel in her first year for town halls and conversations across the organisation. The response helped slow defections, restore energy and support the wider recovery.

Smaller symbolic acts can also signal seriousness. When Nintendo’s Satoru Iwata halved his salary during a downturn to protect jobs and creative talent, or when other Japanese CEOs took similar cuts, the message of shared sacrifice was clear and public.


Where empathy was missing or insufficient

Not every change effort gets this right. In one documented case, senior leaders at a large health insurer spent many months in intense internal debate over a new strategy. Once they finally agreed, they announced it largely by email and expected rapid alignment. Employees reacted with indifference or hostility. The leaders had lived the emotional and intellectual journey. Everyone else was expected to skip it. The resulting gap was predictable.


A peer-reviewed study of a Dutch hospital’s attempt to switch surgical suture suppliers after a tender shows a different failure mode. Formal process was followed, yet cardiothoracic surgeons resisted intensely. The material was not just a product to them. It was bound up with professional identity, tactile expertise, risk judgement and direct patient accountability. When those deeper stakes were not adequately understood or respected, the change was ultimately abandoned for that specialty. Process compliance without insight into meaning proved insufficient.


The recurring patterns are familiar: one-way announcements, underestimation of identity threat, failure to close the time-and-information gap between decision-makers and implementers, and talk of care that is not backed by structural follow-through. Even sincere individual empathy struggles when systems, incentives and power dynamics remain unchanged.


Limits and complements

Empathy is powerful but not a universal solvent. Not all resistance is emotional. Some is strategic, some is self-interested, and some is rooted in genuine value conflict. Over-reliance on empathy can produce preferential treatment, exhaust the leader, or delay necessary hard decisions. Perspective-taking is imperfect. And empathy without clear strategy, resources, role clarity and consistent action quickly feels inauthentic.


The most effective approaches therefore combine genuine audience insight and involvement with disciplined process, clear diagnosis of the type of resistance being faced, and systems that make care visible in how the organisation actually operates.


Practical takeaways

  • Diagnose first. Map who is affected, what they stand to gain or lose, and whether resistance is primarily cognitive, relational or values-based.
  • Close the experience gap. If leaders needed months to accept a change, employees will need time, information and voice too.
  • Make empathy operational. Keep refreshing your understanding of how different groups are experiencing the change. Name real worries. Give people meaningful ways to shape the path.
  • Pair care with clarity and action. People handle difficult truths better than vague reassurance.
  • Watch for the downsides and measure what matters: engagement, adoption speed, voluntary turnover and the quality of ideas coming from the front line.
  • Change remains hard. A surprising amount of the friction, however, is optional. It comes from leaders who move too quickly past the human reality of what they are asking people to do. Empathy does not remove the difficulty. It reduces the unnecessary damage. In a world that keeps demanding more transformation, treating empathy as strategic infrastructure rather than optional niceness is simply good leadership.

 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For help with organisational change enquire about Axis Chart and leadership coaching.